Meta-Analysis of Organic Selenium and Inorganic Selenium on Performance of Laying Hens and Selenium Content in Eggs

  • HE Tao ,
  • DONG Yibo ,
  • WANG Changping ,
  • WEI Chunbo
Expand
  • 1. Key Laboratory of Feed Resource Efficient Utilization and Nutrition Manipulation in Cold Region of Heilongjiang Province, College of Animal Science and Veterinary Medicine, Heilongjiang Bayi Agricultural University, Daqing 163319, China;
    2. Laboratory of Animal and Plant Quarantine, College of Life Sciences, Jiamusi University, Jiamusi 154007, China

Received date: 2021-09-28

  Online published: 2022-04-14

Abstract

The aim of this study was to determine the effects of supplementing organic selenium or inorganic selenium in the diet of laying hens on their performance and egg selenium content by Meta-analysis. The publications searching for organic selenium and inorganic selenium for laying hens were collected from the databases of CNKI, CQVIP, Wanfang, Web of Science, Science direct and Pub Med. The retrieval period was from January 1, 2015 to July 1, 2021. The Meta-analysis was conducted using Comprehensive Meta Analysis V3 software. A random-effect model was used to calculate the standardized mean difference (SMD) and 95% confidence interval (95% CI). A total of 19 articles out of the identified 1 921 articles (8 249 laying hens) were eligible and included in the Meta-analysis. Publication bias was evaluated by funnel plot, and the source of heterogeneity was explained by Meta-regression analysis and regulatory effect analysis. The results showed as follows:compared with inorganic selenium, supplementation of organic selenium in the diet could increase the laying rate (SMD=0.477%, P=0.005), egg weight (SMD=0.697%, P<0.001), feed to egg ratio (SMD=-1.636%, P<0.001) and egg selenium content (SMD=5.965%, P<0.001) more effectively. At the same time, in the selection of laying hens, Hy-Line brown laying hens were better than Roman laying hens, and the test period was positively correlated with the adding dose in the model. In conclusion, adding organic selenium to the diet is better than inorganic selenium, which provides a useful reference for exploring the application of selenium in laying hen production in the future.

Cite this article

HE Tao , DONG Yibo , WANG Changping , WEI Chunbo . Meta-Analysis of Organic Selenium and Inorganic Selenium on Performance of Laying Hens and Selenium Content in Eggs[J]. Chinese Journal of Animal Nutrition, 2022 , 34(4) : 2654 -2666 . DOI: 10.3969/j.issn.1006-267x.2022.04.059

References

[1] 祝保林,魏光民,杨强.富硒预混料的添加对鸡群及鸡蛋品质的影响[J].安徽农学通报,2018,24(13):102-106. ZHU B L,WEI G M,YANG Q.The effects of selenium enriched premix on the quality of chicken and eggs[J].Anhui Agricultural Science Bulletin,2018,24(13):102-106.(in Chinese)
[2] 卢军霞,王娟,褚素乔,等.富硒鸡蛋的研究现状分析[J].今日畜牧兽医,2021,37(5):78-79. LU J X,WANG J,CHU S Q,et al.Analysis on research status of selenium enriched eggs[J].Today’s Animal Husbandry and Veterinary,2021,37(5):78-79.(in Chinese)
[3] 蒋守群.有机硒在动物营养上的研究与应用[J].饲料工业,2005,26(20):43-45. JIANG S Q.Research and application of organic selenium in animal nutrition[J].Feed Industry,2005,26(20):43-45.(in Chinese)
[4] 贺淼,张新,廖灿青,等.酵母硒对海兰褐商品代蛋鸡产蛋性能、蛋硒沉积和硒利用率的影响[J].中国饲料,2020(5):113-117. HE M,ZHANG X,LIAO C Q,et al.Effects of different types of selenium yeast on egg-laying performance,egg selenium deposition and selenium utilization rate of Hy-line variety brown [J].China Feed,2020(5):113-117.(in Chinese)
[5] 苏晓菲.3种硒源在蛋鸡饲料中的有效性评价[J].山西农业科学,2018,46(9):1528-1531. SU X F.Effectiveness evaluation of three selenium sources in laying hens feed[J].Journal of Shanxi Agricultural Sciences,2018,46(9):1528-1531.(in Chinese)
[6] PAYNE R L,LAVERGNE T K,SOUTHERN L L.Effect of inorganic versus organic selenium on hen production and egg selenium concentration[J].Poultry Science,2005,84(2):232-237.  
[7] 李家奎,王小龙.硒的生物转化研究进展[J].中国兽医杂志,2002,38(3):35-37. LI J K,WANG X L.Research progress on biotransformation of selenium[J].Chinese Journal of Veterinary Medicine,2002,38(3):35-37.(in Chinese)
[8] CHEUNG M W L,VIJAYAKUMAR R.A guide to conducting a Meta-analysis[J].Neuropsychology Review,2016,26(2):121-128.  
[9] XU B C,LI Z,WANG C,et al.Effects of fermented feed supplementation on pig growth performance:a Meta-analysis[J].Animal Feed Science and Technology,2020,259:114315.
[10] WAN X,WANG W Q,LIU J M,et al.Estimating the sample mean and standard deviation from the sample size,median,range and/or interquartile range[J].BMC Medical Research Methodology,2014,14:135.
[11] 李乐.富硒乳酸菌培养物对蛋鸡生长性能及相关指标的影响[D].硕士学位论文.延吉:延边大学,2018. LI L.Effect of selenium-enriched Lactobacillus on production performance and correlative index in laying hens[D].Master’s Thesis.Yanji:Yanbian University,2018.(in Chinese)
[12] 胡华锋,杨建平,郭孝,等.不同硒源对蛋鸡生产性能、粪硒含量及饲料硒吸收率的影响[J].家畜生态学报,2015,36(1):32-37. HU H F,YANG J P,GUO X,et al.Effect of selenium source on production performance,fecal selenium content and feed selenium absorption rate of laying hens[J].Acta Ecologae Animalis Domastici,2015,36(1):32-37.(in Chinese)
[13] 齐香萍,张海斌,张瑞铎.不同硒源对蛋鸡生产性能和硒沉积的影响[J].中国饲料,2019(16):60-63. QI X P,ZHANG H B,ZHANG R D.Effects of dietary supplementation of different selenium sources on laying performance and selenium deposition in egg of laying hens[J].China Feed,2019(16):60-63.(in Chinese)
[14] 刘虎.不同硒源及水平对蛋鸡生产性能、蛋品质、蛋硒含量及血液生化指标的影响[D].硕士学位论文.长沙:湖南农业大学,2017. LIU H.Effects of different selenium source and level on performance,egg quality,content of selenium and blood biochemical indicators in laying hens[D].Master’s Thesis.Changsha:Hunan Agricultural University,2017.(in Chinese)
[15] 周建军,胡先勤,王学东,等.几种不同硒源对蛋鸡生产性能、产蛋品质以及蛋硒含量的影响[J].饲料工业,2018,39(11):38-43. ZHOU J J,HU X Q,WANG X D,et al.Effects of different selenium sources on the yield performance,egg quality and egg selenium content of egg chicken[J].Feed Industry,2018,39(11):38-43.(in Chinese)
[16] 张浩,周珍辉,孙健,等.酵母硒对蛋鸡生产性能、蛋品质及蛋中硒含量的影响[J].饲料研究,2020,43(12):121-124. ZHANG H,ZHOU Z H,SUN J,et al.Effect of yeast selenium on production performance,egg quality and egg selenium content of laying hens[J].Feed Research,2020,43(12):121-124.(in Chinese)
[17] 李晓丽,何万领,位治国,等.酵母硒对蛋鸡生产性能、血清生化指标及常规蛋品质的影响[J].中国兽医学报,2015,35(11):1835-1839. LI X L,HE W L,WEI Z G,et al.Effects of yeast-Se on production performance,serum biochemical parameters and egg quality of laying hens[J].Chinese Journal of Veterinary Science,2015,35(11):1835-1839.(in Chinese)
[18] 司雪阳.酵母硒对饲喂膨化亚麻籽型饲粮蛋鸡生产性能、蛋品质和储存稳定性的影响[D].硕士学位论文.北京:中国农业科学院,2020. SI X Y.Influence of yeast selenium on production performance,egg quality and storage stability for laying hens with puffed flaxseed supplemented diet[D].Master’s Thesis.Beijing:Chinese Academy of Agricultural Sciences,2020.(in Chinese)
[19] 孙庆艳,武书庚,张海军,等.饲粮中添加不同硒源对产蛋鸡生产性能和抗氧化能力的影响[J].动物营养学报,2016,28(4):1177-1185. SUN Q Y,WU S G,ZHANG H J,et al.Effects of dietary supplementation of different selenium sources on production performance and antioxidant activity of laying hens[J].Chinese Journal of Animal Nutrition,2016,28(4):1177-1185.(in Chinese)
[20] 石雕.硒对蛋鸡生产性能、血清生化指标及组织硒含量的影响[D].硕士学位论文.杨凌:西北农林科技大学,2019. SHI D.Effects of selenium on production performance,serum biochemical parameters and tissue selenium content in laying hens[D].Master’s Thesis.Yangling:Northwest A & F University,2019.(in Chinese)
[21] 梁林,李晓林,王珏,等.中药富硒酵母对蛋鸡产蛋性能的影响[J].安徽科技学院学报,2020,34(3):1-5. LIANG L,LI X L,WANG J,et al.Effect of Se-enriched yeast cultured in Chinese medicine on hens for egg laying[J].Journal of Anhui Science and Technology University,2020,34(3):1-5.(in Chinese)
[22] JING C L,DONG X F,WANG Z M,et al.Comparative study of DL-selenomethionine vs sodium selenite and seleno-yeast on antioxidant activity and selenium status in laying hens[J].Poultry Science,2015,94(5):965-975.  
[23] LIN X,YANG T,LI H,et al.Interactions between different selenium compounds and essential trace elements involved in the antioxidant system of laying hens[J].Biological Trace Element Research,2020,193(1):252-260.  
[24] MENG T T,LIN X,XIE C Y,et al.Nanoselenium and selenium yeast have minimal differences on egg production and Se deposition in laying hens[J].Biological Trace Element Research,2021,199(6):2295-2302.  
[25] LU J,QU L,SHEN M M,et al.Effects of high-dose selenium-enriched yeast on laying performance,egg quality,clinical blood parameters,organ development,and selenium deposition in laying hens[J].Poultry Science,2019,98(6):2522-2530.  
[26] CHANTIRATIKUL A,CHINRASRI O,CHANTIRATIKUL P.Effect of selenium from selenium-enriched kale sprout versus other selenium sources on productivity and selenium concentrations in egg and tissue of laying hens[J].Biological Trace Element Research,2018,182(1):105-110.  
[27] LIU H,YU Q F,FANG C K,et al.Effect of selenium source and level on performance,egg quality,egg selenium content,and serum biochemical parameters in laying hens[J].Foods,2020,9(1):68.
[28] MENG T T,LIU Y L,XIE C Y,et al.Effects of different selenium sources on laying performance,egg selenium concentration,and antioxidant capacity in laying hens[J].Biological Trace Element Research,2019,189(2):548-555.  
[29] RESHADI H,TORKI M,MOHAMMADI H.Changes in performance,egg quality and blood parameters of laying hens fed selenium and oregano oil[J].Animal Production Science,2020,60(13):1620-1629.  
[30] 孟艳娇.应用酵母硒饲喂蛋鸡试验分析[J].中国畜禽种业,2018,14(1):139-142. MENG Y J.Experimental analysis on feeding layers with yeast selenium[J].The Chinese Livestock and Poultry Breeding,2018,14(1):139-142.(in Chinese)
[31] 赵玉鑫,黄克和,潘翠玲,等.不同硒源及水平对蛋鸡生产性能、蛋品质及蛋硒含量的影响[J].江苏农业科学,2007(6):208-210. ZHAO Y X,HUANG K H,PAN C L,et al.Effect of selenium source and level in dietary on production performance,egg quality and egg selenium concentrations in laying hens[J].Jiangsu Agricultural Sciences,2007(6):208-210.(in Chinese)
[32] DELEZIE E,ROVERS M,VAN DER AA A,et al.Comparing responses to different selenium sources and dosages in laying hens[J].Poultry Science,2014,93(12):3083-3090.  
[33] HASSAN S.Selenium concentration in egg and body tissue as affected by the level and source of selenium in the hen diet[J].Acta Agriculturae Scandinavica,1990,40(3):279-287.  
[34] LEESON S,NAMKUNG H,CASTON L,et al.Comparison of selenium levels and sources and dietary fat quality in diets for broiler breeders and layer hens[J].Poultry Science,2008,87(12):2605-2612.  
[35] 林玲,高源.硒添加水平对仔猪生长性能的影响[J].中国畜牧兽医文摘,2017,33(4):223. LIN L,GAO Y.Effect of selenium addition level on growth performance of piglets[J].Chinese Abstracts of Animal Husbandry and Veterinary Medicine,2017,33(4):223.(in Chinese)
Outlines

/